Is strategy worth the time when there isn't any time?

Dear Trebuchet Group,

Every year at this time, I see other leaders posting about planning retreats and strategy sessions. I know this is the season for that kind of thinking. Frankly, we can't afford a retreat this year.

My team is stretched thin. Budgets are tighter now than they were in January. Most days I'm just putting out one fire after another, and by the time I look up, the week is gone.

Even if I carved out a full day, I'm not sure what we'd get from the effort. Strategy feels like an educated guess at best, and nobody can predict what next quarter will bring.

Is strategy worth the time when there isn't any time?

Signed,

Too Busy Driving to Stop for Gas

Dear Too Busy,

Indeed, strategy is an educated guess at best. My belief is strategy doesn’t mean anything until it is applied, and then we get to see what really works.

You're in good company asking your question. I hear some version of it everywhere this time of year. Nonprofit leaders tell me they're in firefighting mode while the need for their services keeps growing and the resources don't. Managers are seeing headlines about layoffs and budget cuts and wonder if they should be worried. The sky feels like it's falling to some, and yet their team has a job to do on Monday.

I've written before about the addictive pull of firefighting. Putting out fires is AMAZING! Standing in the wet, steaming embers, you can practically hear the trumpet fanfare and cheering in the background! Seriously, fighting fires gives you immediate and positive feedback. You do something and see the difference right away, which feels great. The problem is: if you’re fighting the fires, who’s figuring out how to prevent the fires from even happening in the first place?

Of course your team probably won’t interfere with you as you’re diving in with your sleeves rolled up - you’re good at it, they have lots of other things to do, and you might even criticize their efforts. Worse yet, there’s no incentive for them to give you any warning signs that the business needs you elsewhere. And not getting negative feedback can lull you into a false sense of security.

A personal note on that: six years ago I almost skipped my annual physical. I felt healthy, and taking time for an appointment was just one more thing on my very full plate. The routine blood work flagged a PSA level that had jumped from 4 to 8. Although I had no symptoms, my doctor encouraged me to get a biopsy. Those results weren’t terrible, and a couple of months later I was in the surgery recovery room when the surgeon said: “Oh, by the way, that was Stage 3, but I think we got it all.” After five years of essentially zero PSA levels, I’m living testimony that he did get it all. Looking back, that physical was one of the most important hours I have ever spent in my life.

Skipping strategy doesn't get you out of having one. No strategy is still a strategy. If you keep doing what you're doing, you'll keep getting the results you're getting. That's a choice too, even when nobody writes it down.

So let's set the big strategy session aside for now. Let's try something lighter.

How to keep getting the exact results you are getting

Our colleague Gurudev introduced me to an exercise I keep coming back to. Start by naming the results you're getting right now. Then imagine you've been asked to teach a class: How to Guarantee ANYONE Can Get These Exact Results.

I tried this on myself since, honestly, Trebuchet Group is currently not as successful as I want it to be, financially or in the impact I believe we can make. So here's the class I’d teach on keeping things exactly the way they are.

Fair warning: every item on this list started with good intentions.

How to Make Sure Your Employees Struggle: A Trebuchet Group Masterclass

  • Ask for initiative, then make it a little bit better
    Tell people you want them to own their work. When they bring it to you, add your 10%, every time. Soon they'll learn that their version is the first draft and yours is the real one, and they'll stop bringing you finished work at all.

  • Solve it "just this once"
    When someone brings you a challenge, explain exactly how you would handle it. Then offer to take it off their plate, just this once. Do this every week, and before long your team will be excellent at one thing: finding problems that need you.

  • Write job descriptions for unicorns
    List everything the role needs, then add the parts of your own job you enjoy most. When no human on earth fits the description, take it as proof that good help is hard to find.

  • Hire for different strengths, then grade on yours
    Bring in people who think differently than you do. It's great for the team. Then measure their work against how you would have done it, and act a little surprised each time it doesn't match.

  • Be highly collaborative, yet hold a strong opinion about what will work
    Invite everyone's ideas and listen with real interest. Then let your follow-up questions steer the group toward elements you know will work. Your team will learn the game quickly and start guessing your answer instead of offering their own.

  • Keep your disappointment a secret
    Hold standards so high nobody quite knows what they are. When someone misses, say nothing directly so you don’t make them feel bad. Quietly redo their work after hours. Hope they'll figure it out eventually.

  • Keep the work you love and the work you hate
    Hang on to the tasks you're great at, since nobody does them quite like you. Hang on to the tasks you dislike too, since it would be unkind to burden anyone else with them. Your team gets whatever is left over, and you get your evenings back sometime next year.

Writing my habits as a class makes them easier to see, and honestly, easier to laugh at.

What would your class be?

This one takes about twenty minutes and some wry honesty.

  • Write down the results you're getting, especially the ones you don’t want.

  • Then edit to get your syllabus: three to five things you'd teach someone to guarantee those same results. The more specific (and ruthless) you get, the better this becomes.

Here's your homework if you want it: Pick the item that made you wince the most and try the opposite for two weeks. Keep a few notes. If it breaks you out of a habit you didn’t know you were practicing, great - tell your team what you're doing differently and why. If the old habit keeps winning, that's normal, and it's right where we love to help leaders break through. Let’s find time for a conversation.

Yours,
Chris

Coming up next: Every class on what isn't working leaves something out.

Next month, we'll flip the coin and look at what IS working, and how you and your team can get more of the good stuff as you head into the new year.